Azrael... theres no reason to fear me.

For I am but conjurer and procurers of such

Fine, lynch me if you like. I guess it's claim time: Prince. I've been in a really depressed mood for the past couple days, so if I get offed in the night that'd be even better. After this, votes will most likely be all you get. G'night.

Norm stole my Alice in Wonderland idea!

It's okay; on the long drive back home, I thought of dozens of clues/red herrings... for three people. Sorry, Azrael/Lotus/Farty.

I'm guessing that Norm wouldn't blatantly take my idea exactly the way I proposed it in the shoutbox, so the clue likely does not point to Azrael.

Time to dodge, everyone!

Who says it was pointing to Azrael? Maybe it was pointing to the idea creator.

I don't think poison is the prince, I would have not told my role to anyone other then the king if i was. Maybe he is doing it because of the low likelihood of the king dying but revealing it this early is pretty stupid.

EDIT: Roy I trust you so when I don't have time to examine the clues myself I'll vote for whoever you want me to vote for.

Gonna give any reasoning why or are you just gonna try and start a bandwagon?


I seem to want to believe poison... his post seemed pretty sincere.

That seems strictly unlikely and doesn't even make sense. "Oh yes, this clue that points to this user obviously is, in actuality, pointing to the person who gave norm the idea." Nah dawg.

Poison never even claimed to be bard. He just said "i sent in my claim as soon as..." never specifying his claim in his post.

My bad. I assumed that poison was attempting to CC bard with his post, which really would have left him guilty.

Raccoon is being suspicious in PMs as well. I am assuming he is dark avenger and was not told who the rest of the mafia are.

Im highly interested, please tell me more.

If anyone CCs Bard, then we have to kill them. If they are Bard, then we have to kill Aristocrat. It's pretty simple.


Tell me that doesn't sound like a Bard CC.


Nah dawg, Roy says something in the shoutbox and Norm copies it verbatim into the Night post, it makes perfect sense that it could point to the person who said it

One thing's for sure, if Roy or Tikels turn out to be Mafia, kill the other one immediately.

It DOESN'T sound like a bard CC. It's all in interpretation... poison came back and said "i wasn't claiming to be a bard". Stop trying to confuse us. There is no CC. Case settled.
I just saw it as a "I claimed to be something in PM" not "I claimed to be a bard in PM".

Well, I'm pretty new to mafia, so you might be right about roy being mafia. I don't know. I'm not gonna rush to any conclusions (until tomorrow )

How in the world did I get suddenly "allied with Roy." All I did was give my opinion.

It did, which is why Poison came back to clarify it later.


Someone pointed out a clue that points to both me and Roy. You step in and say "NO NOT ROY!!! IT WOULD MAKE NO SENSE, IT WOULD DEFY ALL LOGIC!!! THERES JUST NO WAY IT COULD BE ROY, NO WAY AT ALL!!! IMPOSSIBLE, JUST IMPOSSIBLE!!!"

Paraphrasing. If you weren't allied to Roy then you'd have no reason to get so defensive about him. It makes perfect sense that the clue would point to him, so you trying to say he shouldn't even be considered as a suspect is suspicious.

I didn't think it did. It's an opinion.

Exaggerated, I thought the logic itself was weak, that someone who MENTIONS alice in wonderland ONCE in the shoutbox is then culpable. Look, I'm not saying I was right, but maybe I just don't know mafia. DW I'm not mafia.

Oh good, then I'm not screwed...

Wait... I argued against Taylor's clues towards Poison in the shoutbox... FUUUUUUUUUUUU-

When I play as mafia, I'm just gonna defend townies hardcore and then get killed. Then Azrael will have a list of non-mafia that people will bandwagon

Edit: I know that nobody has thrown this out as a suggestion, but did you consider that Norm just put the Alice in Wonderland reference in as a red herring to make us all go ballistic towards each other? If so, it worked.

Post has been edited 2 time(s), last time on Sep 19 2010, 5:21 pm by Roy.

The point was that the clue pointed to both me and Roy, yet you only got defensive about Roy. If it was just because you thought the logic was weak, then you'd have defended both of us equally.

Also, the logic is quite solid. Roy, while talking to Norm in the shoutbox, says he would use a clue that quotes Alice in Wonderland. In Norm's very next post, he included a quote from Alice in Wonderland. It's a pretty straightforward conclusion.


It's a possibility, otherwise one of us would definitely be Mafia, and since I know I'm not Mafia, I'd be saying you are 100% guilty

Make sure you guys finish all your night actions before 11pm today (you got like nine hours). Sun will rise shortly after that.

he made me go ballistic over Demon clues

You did that to yourself.

Where do you live?

! I blame Demon for contradicting his own innocence.

@Zilean, Obvious east coast is obvious.

Way to blow the revolution.