To shift blame implies there was blame in the first place. All of your blame is based purely on nothing, so where does the blame actually exist?

I should pardon Apos after all you guys vote for him. ;D

Also, everyone PM me your roles.

...why?

Mafia can just lie. You gain no actual information.

Oh, great. Now we need to lynch the king, too.

[/kidding]

Wouldn't he gain the identities of all the power rules?

... Silly game.

Say we have this scenario: One Mafia claims doctor. Now we know that one of the three people who claimed doctor was lying. However, lynching them is not in our favor. Worse yet, one doctor forgets to claim, and now the king thinks a mafia member is doctor.

By claiming power roles, mafia members can almost completely shut down the information gained by the king.

I vote Apos.
Final decision.

Of course we do. Everyone should be giving their roles to Demonslayer.

If anyone CCs a role, then we know one of them is Mafia. We can choose to lynch them now, or wait until later when there's fewer Mafia and thus more to be gained by sacrificing power roles to kill them. The choice is ours either way.


Not right now it isn't, but if it gets down to 1 or 2 Mafia left and there are 3 people who've claimed Doctor, it is certainly in our best interests to start killing them off. If it comes to that, the King can name one at random and we lynch them.


1) If one Doctor "forgets" to claim, then he's a bad Doctor and will probably "forget" to protect people too.

2) It's not like the King is going to tell him anyone else's role. The Doctors should, at the very least, inform the King of who they are protecting/shielding each night. If one Doctor is protecting, and the other is shielding, then the person becomes vulnerable to normal hits. The King could then tell the person who is shielding "You need to change your target to someone else."

If the King is confident they are legit after a period of time, he can direct them to protect specific targets.

Having more information is definitely for the best. The King can decide what to do with the information he receives depending on what happens in the game and any inconsistencies in said information.


Better to have some wrong information then no information at all. The King will of course be aware that one of them is lying, and can handle it accordingly from there. If it gets near the end of the game, when there are very few Mafia left, then the Mafia who lied has committed suicide.

If apos isn't mafia I say we lynch poison. Swift's got some good clues

I vote apos

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Sep 17 2010, 9:05 pm by Tempz.

;D All this makes it hard for me to find an excuse... I am mafia but I'm not supposed to say it right? It seems so hard to hide it though ;D

I don't really know how to defend myself.

I am too young to die? Don't lynch me?

Anyway, if I die, I say to all mafias to kill Azrael this night. I don't know yet who the other mafias are so that's why I'm saying it publicly. I just want you to know that Azrael, Aristocrat and Poison should be your first targets, they got the most power. I hope that I have helped you in a way, all my mafia friends.

(Luke, I am your father!)
(May the force by with you!)

AND... GUILLOTINE THE KING!!! (As soon as possible please!)

Optimal winning strategy from my point of view:

- All townspeople should dodge on the first turn. This forces mafia players to consolidate their hits to two mafia per target to get kills, and at most three townspeople will die. If doctors get lucky, only one townie dies.
- Channeler should not channel at all, as there are more townspeople using magic than heretics.
- The ghost should not haunt either, as more townspeople use magic than mafia.
- The black wizard should use DBL lightning on LoTu)S.

Aristocrat has the 3 people and 5 asian symbols 3 x 5 = 15 solders

To prevent Ghost from allying with mafia, everyone should claim ghost when a mafia dies.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Sep 17 2010, 9:24 pm by Roy. Reason: No reason

Though there is a hub player, people are still stupid when giving roles. I'm not sure if anyone remembers Gotham City Mafia, but Ashamed was the pardoner and pardoned someone and revealed that he was a townie to all the players. All people were still reluctant to give their roles, and Greo, our boondock saint, claimed doctor for no apparent reason, which still puzzles me to this day why a power role lies about being another power role. Batman ends up losing an investigate because Greo was an idiot, I just hope this doesn't happen this game, go townie power!

-Haters gonna hate.

This line irks me. It's either a typo, or maybe he's talking about Will Smith (or Men in Black) or he's talking about Robert Downy Jr's film, the Last Party (1993) where someone says "there is no black man named smith and wesson" ( www.youtube.com/watch?v=_zgkWu5Z9AY#t=2m24s ). Not sure, it's most likely a typo. So is anyone a fan of Robert Downy Jr, Will Smith or MIB?

It's a joke. Black man named smith. Black, smith. Blacksmith. Medieval times. Hence why "smith" isn't capitalized.

How many black men were there around medieval Europe, anyway?