Rate sigs
Aug 13 2008, 4:45 pm
By: BiOAtK  

Aug 13 2008, 4:45 pm BiOAtK Post #1



These are my first to projects ever on Photoshop, so please critique and I will take it into account and try to fix it!
Thanks





Oh, by the way, BiO is another forum name I have.



None.

Aug 13 2008, 6:43 pm SiN Post #2



first one is okay. but your smudging gives it absolutely no flow. it appears like you smudged (or brushed) a background and then placed a render on top. it just doesn't work for me.

second one is bad compared to the first one. The render quality is terrible, dont use a render like that. you made no attempt to blend the render either. The background has way different colors and is completely random compared to the render. and so it doesnt fit. You also need to fix the lighting up.



None.

Aug 13 2008, 7:47 pm EzDay281 Post #3



First suggestion: Border.
With a few exceptions, I'll just about always advocate, at the very least, a 1px black-line border. ;P Though in the case of this, something slightly more obnoxious would be in order, since black would meld with parts of the image.
First one seems kind of random. Find a smaller biohazzard symbol, I might suggest, or else have some effect going on where it cuts off, instead of just... not.
The background, as SiN mentioned, seems kind of random, and, visually, it clashes with the focus. It seems to hold no sense of pattern - and while you may be going for a relatively "chaotic" appearance, it bears noting that, something people recognize naturally, almost any random splatter will have some degree of order or tendencies in it.

...
Also, I'm dehydrated, low blood sugary, sleep deprived, and generally exhausted, so I'll probably be thinking, "WTF? I look like an idiot" when I read this post later. =D



None.

Aug 13 2008, 7:53 pm MadZombie Post #4



Eh so this is like your first sig? tbh i think its too early to be taking criticism until you've gotten yourself familiar with the program. Someone might be like "OMFG Clipping mask on the render and then Filter>diffuse>234332235." and you'd be like "teh wuts?"

play with it some moar.
http://www.good-tutorials.com/



None.

Aug 14 2008, 3:21 am EzDay281 Post #5



Quote
Eh so this is like your first sig? tbh i think its too early to be taking criticism until you've gotten yourself familiar with the program.
Firstly, about 99% of signature-making is just style. It should always be critiqued, as improving it is generally an extremely straight-forward process, until one has such an understanding of the subject that they don't need to have the philosophy of crticism explained to them.
Secondly, you learn how to use a program in large part by... using it! Crazy prospect, I know.

edit: Hell, take my suggestions for example. A border. Anyone can do that. A more ideally sized image. Again, simple. Add some warping or blurring effect near the bottom of the image. ... Redo the entire signature, and design it such that it forms a coherent image. While that's a rather more tricky task, it is, in this case, a matter of skill, not of understanding one's software.
Quote
Someone might be like "OMFG Clipping mask on the render and then Filter>diffuse>234332235." and you'd be like "teh wuts?"
I don't even touch Photoshop and that makes some sense to me. lolwut.



None.

Options
  Back to forum
Please log in to reply to this topic or to report it.
Members in this topic: None.
[11:29 pm]
Vrael -- idk what I did but I like triple-posted in SD sorry
[02:45 pm]
NudeRaider -- Oh_Man
Oh_Man shouted: have i ever told u guys my SC2 pro-gamer story
how many GSL titles?
[2026-7-27. : 10:41 am]
ManCubuS -- Seems like something's broken regarding the site then. Sadge...
[2026-7-27. : 7:36 am]
Oh_Man -- have i ever told u guys my SC2 pro-gamer story
[2026-7-26. : 11:30 pm]
Ultraviolet -- That's strange, it looks like you targeted the base image file (sometimes people make the mistake of just using the imgur page link which doesn't work for embedding) but it still didn't work it sounds like.
[2026-7-26. : 3:34 pm]
ManCubuS -- Used : " [img=https://i.imgur.com/gpOjTuD.jpeg] "
[2026-7-26. : 3:28 pm]
ManCubuS -- Even tried with imgur, doesn't attach.
[2026-7-26. : 3:14 pm]
ManCubuS -- I should try a workaround, thanks! Sadly imgur is blocked in my country for some unknown reason.
[2026-7-26. : 3:05 pm]
NudeRaider -- I think SEN has trouble with https or hotlinking is forbidden. It certainly is nothing about the size, it just fails to get any size. You can get it working if you use imgur and include the actual image link for the img tag. Like this: [img=https://i.imgur.com/ddYqXZa.jpeg]
[2026-7-26. : 11:15 am]
ManCubuS -- Hey fellas! Anyone knows why when I try to upload an image it says "failed to get image size"? I even tried making it so small. Imgur isn't working here and I tried postimg no luck.
Please log in to shout.


Members Online: Symmetry