The biggest things in there to me are "FACE," "Escape," and the "255." I'd like to think the pest thing is important, but it seems very vague. I also think the "Boom. Headshot." was just Norm's way of speaking, but that's mostly due to the fact that I can't really piece that with anything.
When I read "FACE," I immediately thought of avatars with faces. That's a very simple observation, but the thing that sort of sets off red herring warnings is that we have a bunch of people with avatars of peoples' faces. Then I got to thinking about perhaps people posting in the post your pics thread. That's sending me on loops, though, too.
For "Escape," I also liken it to the oddly capitalized words from Norm Mafia #1. Though Norm could know we'd think about that and throw this in to confuse us, but I do like where Leeroy is going with his analysis.
Lastly with the "255," I can't help but think that is important. I checked member
#255, members with
255 activity (of which there are none as of right now), members with
255 posts (none in that range are playing Mafia), and even
shout #255. Nothing is really sticking, so I'm not sure about this one just yet.
So far I think Raccoon is an easy choice due to the pest comment, his weird cryptic messages seen as lies, and even the fact that he has a face in his avatar

. Other than that, I suppose I can follow Leeroy's logic against Azrael. Though I do also agree with poison that Aristo's "Wow we were inefficient this turn." is a very odd choice of phrasing, I'm guessing he's referring to all of us wasting our dodges.
For now, I'll wait to vote until tomorrow in case anyone comes up with something more substantial.
Currently Working On:
Myself