It hasn't even been 2 days and DTBK will most likely be busy so I'm guessing tuesday or wed

hahahaha, what is going on!!!

I vote Devourer

How come your not going to kill the obvious mafia victim over a suspectable mafia!? You know your going to kill a mafia 100%, rather than FatalException, who has a chance of being a townie?

I vote dev!

Corbo worked out that fewer people die if we kill FE.

Which includes mafia, does it not?

No. Well, a mafia may die, but the amount of townies dead is still less this way.

It's not that we're going after a "suspectable" mafia.
We're just going for the fact that least people die if we do not kill devourer and that if we do not kill him it doesn't matter anyway, cause he can either be jailed or killed by the BDS...etc.
Why waste a lynch on someone that we already know he's mafia? let other roles handle it. Plus if we kill FE, there's a chance that the joker will tell us a mafia.

Devourer will eventually die. Just not this time, if devourer hadn't been revealed tonight we'd be lynching FE away.

Or there's a chance the Joker could lie to us and tell us a townsperson, he doesn't have any obligations to anyone, not us or the Mafia. So if he tells us a person that is "supposely" Mafia, and it turns out to be a townie? Then we're idiots for listening him, vote Devourer down and get rid of Mafia.

Regardless of the joker lying, which he probably will, we still lose fewer townies this way.

There's also a chance that the joker is a human person and that when he saw that the mafia didn't hit FE at all he felt bad and QQ'd and now wants revenge?
And there's also a chance that the joker already gave us the mafia *cough*

gee, I said I was not defending this anymore. God you people do not think ahead.

We would also kill more mafia this way, a guaranteed death of at least one mafia along with two possible joker hits + a bds hit.

We could also lose the BDS and doctor...it's more risky letting the joker hit peeps. If the BDS kills dev, then there's a dead mafia. If the mafia doctor protects dev, then the doctor doesn't get his hit. So vote FE, and save lives and potentially kill a mafia.

Listen, I'm not telling you that the joker isn't going to lie to us, or that the plan is 100% safe nor that FE is actually mafia (don't be surprised if he actually isn't) All I am saying is that least people die this way and with a chance of the joker not actually being lieing and him telling us a mafia. You can do whatever you wish, I promise to not post until the night post anymore.

Wouldn't it be better to just lynch Devourer now and let the BDS hit someone else? This would be a lot safer tbh. If the mafia hits comes before the BDS hits, that means Devourer will get a hit tonight, unless we lynch him.

Or someone can redirect his hit into another Mafia, or he can be jailed. Wasting a lynch is silly.

OMG. THERE'S A WAY TO FIGURE OUT WHAT HAPPENS BEFORE WHAT!?!!?!?!?

WHO KNEW!?!?!?

Says the man who typed my name incorrectly, in two places. Regardless, I haven't seen The Dark Knight, nor do I know enough about the Batman series as a whole to make the detailed posts the Joker has.

I vote FatalException, and leave DeVouReR to Boondock Saints.
The reasoning behind this should be obvious: lynch obvious mafia, avoid possibly losing two townies, and possibly probably get a confirmed mafioso.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 26 2009, 3:05 am by poison_us. Reason: see [s]

Just so you people don't blame me after.

WE DON'T KNOW IF FATALEXCEPTION IS MAFIA. HE PROBABLY ISN'T, HE PROBABLY IS.


If you were voting for him because you thought he was, you should re-read all the posts since the day started and reconsider your vote.

The one exception to this is if a Boondock Saint targets a mafia who is killing him. In the case of such a confrontation, the Saint wins. However, if another mafia is gunning down the Saint, he doesn't get his hit off.

DTBK, if the BDS hits FE in night can that be counted or not?