Let's cut the flaming before I pull out the lightning bolts. Analyze your clues and throw down your votes, that's all you have to do. The amount of douchebaggery someone puts forth is not a clue.

This is my current count.

frazz :: NerdyTerdy -> Dapperdan
~:Deathawk:~ :: Dapperdan (#2)
NerdyTerdy :: frazz -> Dapperdan (#3)
FatalException :: Crimson Magnum -> Dapperdan (#4)
Crimson Magnum :: frazz -> Dapperdan (#5)
Doodan :: NerdyTerdy -> Dapperdan (#6)
ClansAreForGays :: Dapperdan (#7)
Doktor Shotgun :: Dapperdan (#8)
Merrell :: Dapperdan (#9)
ToA :: Dapperdan (#10)

Ejac :: NerdyTerdy
Cob :: NerdyTerdy (#2)
Nimitz :: NerdyTerdy (#3)
Laser Dude :: NerdyTerdy (#4)
Heegu :: NerdyTerdy (#5)
Dapperdan :: frazz -> Cheeze -> NerdyTerdy (#6)
omginbd :: frazz -> Dapperdan -> Cob -> NerdyTerdy (#7)
Jello-Jigglers :: frazz -> Cob -> NerdyTerdy (#8)
Twitch :: frazz -> NerdyTerdy (#9)
cheeze :: Dapperdan -> NerdyTerdy (#10)

WoAHorde :: Cob
l)ark_ssj9kevin :: Cob (#2)
moneylover :: frazz -> Cob (#3)
Cnl.Fatso :: Cob (#4)
DT_Battlekruser :: NerdyTerdy -> Cob (#5)

Chuiu :: frazz

Zycorax :: Yoshi da Sniper

dumbducky :: Syphon

EcHo :: EcHo

29 of 45 votes are in.

You've responded to my prayers!

My vote remains on Dapperdan.

I think the best strategy in this stage of the game is to accuse everyone, and see how they react. Also, pretending to be other people can be very effective if you play it right, but first night doesn't really matter who you pretend to be...

oh and moose, everyone is flaming cause the debates are at a stand still, maybe you might consider ending the first day when have the votes are in(next game of coarse) Just a thought...

@ everyone mad at echo: echo's vote is clearly within his rights, maybe he's the town idiot and he just isn't that good at it?

Tough. Just read 14 pages...

I somehow missed the start... O.o

Well considering all that happened I am for double lynching Cob and Nerdy.
Strongest arguments for Nerdy are that he tried to defend someone who had no strong evidence pointing at him, his surprising activity, and especially his PM that he obviously wrote to everyone.
Well and for cob... his reaper really fits slashing... It's not much but its everything we got atm.

Also - though I never played it - it seems to me that lynching many ppl is a good strategy (even it was totally random, which the two ppl I accuse are not!). Because Mafia is going to kill 5 townies and 0 Mafia a night which is 0% for a Mafia kill. When we lynch someone theres a chance 1:7,5 (= 13%) that its a mafia (again this chance is for totally random). That means the more ppl we lynch the closer we come to the the 13% max. If we'd lynch nobody we we had 0% of surviving.
So far the maths for the first night.

This shouldn't be a call for all townies to start killing sprees but not to hesitate if there's a clue leading to someone. The math's on our side!

btw. im a regular townsperson.
That's why I demand a doctor too! (first come, first served (second, actually, but nvm:D)) -- Yes, I want to live... -lol

I Vote cob

Oh and one question: How is this double lynch thing working?
Rules say nothing about it.

I'd like to put my vote the way nerdy terdy AND cob are going down....

If two or more people have a tie vote between them, they both (or all) get lynched. If you want both Nerdy and Cob to go down, it appears you would want to vote for Cob at the moment. I will add that to the rules.

Current Count

frazz :: NerdyTerdy -> Dapperdan
~:Deathawk:~ :: Dapperdan (#2)
NerdyTerdy :: frazz -> Dapperdan (#3)
FatalException :: Crimson Magnum -> Dapperdan (#4)
Crimson Magnum :: frazz -> Dapperdan (#5)
Doodan :: NerdyTerdy -> Dapperdan (#6)
ClansAreForGays :: Dapperdan (#7)
Doktor Shotgun :: Dapperdan (#8)
Merrell :: Dapperdan (#9)
ToA :: Dapperdan (#10)

Ejac :: NerdyTerdy
Cob :: NerdyTerdy (#2)
Nimitz :: NerdyTerdy (#3)
Laser Dude :: NerdyTerdy (#4)
Heegu :: NerdyTerdy (#5)
Dapperdan :: frazz -> Cheeze -> NerdyTerdy (#6)
omginbd :: frazz -> Dapperdan -> Cob -> NerdyTerdy (#7)
Jello-Jigglers :: frazz -> Cob -> NerdyTerdy (#8)
Twitch :: frazz -> NerdyTerdy (#9)
cheeze :: Dapperdan -> NerdyTerdy (#10)

WoAHorde :: Cob
l)ark_ssj9kevin :: Cob (#2)
moneylover :: frazz -> Cob (#3)
Cnl.Fatso :: Cob (#4)
DT_Battlekruser :: NerdyTerdy -> Cob (#5)
MasterJohnny -> Cob (#6)

Chuiu :: frazz

Zycorax :: Yoshi da Sniper

dumbducky :: Syphon

EcHo :: EcHo

30 of 45 votes are in.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 29 2007, 1:20 am by Mini Moose 2707.

Vote cob in that case.

You can't vote for a double lynch. You vote for one person, a double lynch is the result of a tie, should Mini Moose decide it. With that last part, everyone's going to think you're mafia, though...

Hypocrite.

Read the PM I sent you.

Ok, got it. I vote for cob!

And about fatal... "With that last part, everyone's going to think you're mafia, though..."
lol... nothing more to say about it

I wonder if we could triple-lynch. That would be exciting. I'm more and more convinced Nerdy is mafia, but I want to see some more people die, too. I'm leaving my vote till the tie is broken.

... what makes you think that? There's no real concrete evidence against me, just Dapperdan's theory that we should eliminate random people hoping one of them is mafia..

Edit: Anyone find DTBK's wanting to get as many people lynched at once as possible as suspicious? I mean three innocents lynched in a day would be a mafia's dream, no?

Post has been edited 2 time(s), last time on Oct 29 2007, 1:37 am by NerdyTerdy.

Yes, that is clearly exactly what my theory is on how to play. /sarcasm

Yet tripling our odds of killing a mafia member when we ourselves are at our strongest is a towny's dream, when one considers that the entire game is a race.
Besides, as I've mentioned before, the more that anyone does, the more interesting the game is.
Or, in my case, the more amusing it is watching people act stupidly.
I mean, we've so far got Nerdy, Cob, DTBK, and Dapperdan having been called 'suspicious' for playing.

I agree.


I was thinking the exact same thing, actually. He even said earlier he doesn't think I'm mafia but now seems to have no care if I die.

But wanting to lynch that many people purely randomly is still pretty bad odds. You still have 65% chance of getting only townies (I think).

.:.: VOTES :.
VOTER :: VOTED FOR


frazz :: Dapperdan
:Deathhawk:~ ::Dapperdan (#2)
NerdyTerdy :: Dapperdan (#3)
FatalException :: Dapperdan (#4)
Doodan :: Dapperdan (#5)
ClansAreForGays :: Dapperdan (#6)
Doktor Shotgun :: Dapperdan (#7)
Merrell :: Dapperdan (#8)
ToA :: Dapperdan (#9)
dumbduck :: Dapperdan (#10)

Ejac :: NerdyTerdy
Cob :: NerdyTerdy (#2)
Nimitz :: NerdyTerdy (#3)
Laser Dude :: NerdyTerdy (#4)
Heegu :: NerdyTerdy (#5)
Dapperdan :: NerdyTerdy (#6)
omginb :: NerdyTerdy (#7)
Jello-Jigglers :: NerdyTerdy (#8)
Twitch :: NerdyTerdy (#9)
cheeze :: NerdyTerdy (#10)


WoAHorde :: CoB
l)ark_ssj9kevin :: CoB (#2)
moneylover :: CoB (#3)
Cnl.Fatso. :: CoB (#4)
DT_Battlekruser :: CoB (#5)
MasterJohnny :: CoB (#6)
NudeRaider :: CoB (#7)
CrimsonMagnum :: CoB (#8)
Laser Dude :: CoB (#9)


chui. :: frazz

Zycorax :: Yoshi da Sniper

EcHo :: EcHo


.:.: CLUES :.

- Mini Moose 2707 DDFFBB

- town square next to a statue.

- rural town.

- been slashed several times

- finished off with a shot through the head.

- body was completely drained of blood.

- antlers had been sawed off and removed.

- could not be located.


Tell me if I missed you, or messed up on your vote.
lol frazz got off the hook.

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Oct 29 2007, 2:22 am by moneylover.

I'm getting 60%.