Thoughts?

Here's the map attached.

Attachments:

Wow very cool!

First thing that comes to mind is placing tanks or blink stalkers up on the cliffs behind the bottom right starting position, but I don't know if the map edges would allow that.

This map reminds me of fighting spirit (like the best map ever) from BW, except this is a 2 player map.

Again, I'd really like to try playing on this map. I'm not super skilled at critiquing melee maps, so I sadly can't give you more input on this one

Thanks.

The map edges would allow that if I hadn't used a dynamic pathing filler up there to prevent all ground unit travel.

Well, there are a few things that I think I could've done better, but we'll see. I need some input before I just go modify something.

Take people's opinions with a grain of salt at this stage, but I don't really like the middle. Looks like it'd make for really awkward battles. Natural looks like it's too small for my liking, too.

Tanks on cliffs around all the expos?? Not sure if this "no-no" carried over from Brood War, but it looks like terran can wreck everything, especially around the main. The small ramp into the nat and the narrow path that goes around the main is the perfect spot for tanks to rape. Also, it looks like the gold expos will either be impossible to hold or impossible to break through. Terran can turtle and place tanks on cliffs. Maybe open up the mid, get rid of the path from 12/6 expos around main, make 12/6 expos islands, and connect the two ramps that lead into the nat?

I don't know shit about SC2 melee, so I could be complete wrong on all these points.

EDIT: Wow I just realized this is from 4 months ago. Maybe you're still working on it?

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Feb 28 2011, 8:42 pm by Dem0nS1ayer.

Only problem i see is the narrow paths

Post has been edited 1 time(s), last time on Mar 14 2011, 5:38 pm by Tempz.